Book 2 Post 2

What We Don't Talk About When We Talk About Fat was an interesting read and it made me think about how much anti-fat bias there is in this world. Throughout the book, there were a number of anecdotes that showed how unfavorable many everyday experiences can be for fat people. For example, going to work is such a daunting task. There are countless judgemental stares. If they're unlucky, they'll meet an angry, unreasonable person that'll harass them relentlessly. Also, I don't understand how some people have the audacity to dictate what others should eat. I was shocked when the elderly woman removed the melon from the author's grocery cart because it was too high in sugar.

This book also made me realize how much our culture can influence the desirability of a certain body shape. In different eras, certain body shapes were desirable based on the meaning we gave to them. For example, there was a period of time where fat bodies were desirable because they meant prosperity. Today, however, obesity is perceived as a crisis, and this view is supported by prominent individuals such as Michelle Obama and Oprah Winfrey. Even in movies, many fat bodies are often assumed to have a comedic role. For example, a fat character having a hard time completing a task, such as chasing a criminal, would often elicit laughter. Fat women are rarely a romantic interest in films. 

However, there are some points that I don't agree with the author. I believe people should pursue health, especially if they are capable of doing so. I think there are some flaws to her argument because she never addresses some of the important solutions. Most of her argument against being healthy is focused on losing weight through dieting and how it is not sustainable. A healthy lifestyle has never been about losing weight. It's about exercise and eating clean. Losing weight is just a byproduct. She says she does swimming, but swimming is mainly a cardio exercise. There also needs to be an adequate amount of strength training to build muscle because doing so will increase your resting metabolism. When she does mention strength training, she treats building muscle mass as something negative because it won't lower the number on the scale. Also, exercise is sustainable. It does not require any money. Calisthenics is an entire category of strength training exercise focused on using your own body weight.

Comments

  1. I liked reading your post. I think that the perception of our body structure is so fluid, and depends on the prevailing opinion of the environment and social criticism and I think it's something that has to be changed. Also I agree that healthy lifestyle is about exercise and eating clean and healthy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Public perception definitely influences biases against people who are "fat". It's unfortunate that society looks down or makes fun of people simply because of their physical appearance. I agree with your statement that a healthy lifestyle isn't about losing weight. People are often motivated to go on a diet or exercise because they want to lose weight, but it should be more about having a healthy life and in a sense, a better quality of life.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This seems like a super interesting book and I can't wait to take a look. It's interesting how social media has such a huge impact on body perception, including apps that can morph your body and face to look exactly how you desire them. It creates such insecurities among people, and it's important to talk about!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with your last point on her argument about being healthy is focused on losing way. People diet for many reasons, but going on a diet is only associated with losing weight. When I go on diets, I just mean changing my eating habits to exclude too much sugar or unhealthy products.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It sounds like everyone who read this book had some great takeaways. Body shaming and anti-overweight prejudice is just plain wrong. A person's weight should not determine whether they are viewed as healthy and attractive as much as it has in the past.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Unsure why I am listed as unknown. This is Joe Skinner.

      Delete
  6. I agree with your comment about how different bodies are seen as desirable at different points in time. Although exercise is good, this new culture, especially in Los Angeles, has become way too fixated on fitness which is exactly why skinny bodies are seen as so beautiful now. You are right that the media does romanticize skinny bodies way too much.

    ReplyDelete
  7. We're on the same page for most of your post until the end, my interpretation--not that either of ours is wrong or right--was that people conflated the pursuit of health with the pursuit of weight loss and that she wanted to condone that practice, not pursuing health as a whole. I also agree with your point about strength training being important; it makes me think of though how hard that must be for a fat person to do. Most people don't own their own weights so they have to go to a gym to do strength training and subject themselves to further judgement, deterring them from strength training.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi David, I really like that you are able to points that you don't agree with the author. One of my best friend at USC was deemed as "fat" before and one day she decided to lose weight. She started to do lots of weight training and eat pretty health since then. Now, even though she is still slightly "fat" in common viewpoint, she is way much healthier than before. And as her friend, I am very happy for her. I think exercise and working out in a certain extent is necessary but might vary given everyone has different circumstances.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment